How did you spend Christmas? I got up at 4:45 in the morning, caught a cab to the airport and flew to Argentina. Ten hours later, I was surrounded by loved ones, which is pretty cool.
Air travel always plays havoc with any books I might be reading. I invariably finish them on airplanes (yes, I know that superstition says that you're not supposed to finish books on airplanes, but I always do it and have yet to meet my end in a fiery crash - and I travel on airplanes A LOT).
This flight allowed me to finish reading "The Doom that Came to Sarnath", my first ever collection of Lovecraft stories. How can a published author of both science fiction and fantasy not have read any Lovecraft before his 32nd birthday? Weeeelll.... Truth is, I got hooked on Specfic through Asimov and Heinlein on the Sci fi side and light Fantasy (Asprin, Gardner) on the Fantasy side. I eventually read Tolkien and moved to heroic and epic fantasy, but never realy went for the darker stuff or horror, excet the "must read" classics such as Dracula, Poe and Phantom of the Opera. So no Lovecraft, even though I've been aware of his work since I was a teenager.
The edition of "Sarnath" that I read is a Del Rey reprint of the Ballantine "Adult Fantasy" paperback from 1971 (it's obviously not a new thing - anything referred to as "adult fantasy" today would get banned by church and state before reaching the shelves - and then it would immediately sell a million copies on the interent). It's complete, including Lin Carter's introduction and comments, which add a lot to the reading, placing each story in context and telling you quite a bit about the author - which, in this case was invluabe.
The stories themselves are not part of the Cthulhu mythos, except peripherally, and come before the classic Lovecraft. So this might not be the best selection of his work (even Carter admits that some of the stories in the collection are "uninspired"). Nevertheless, this is definitely a great place to start if you intend, as I do, to read more of Lovecraft's work. It allows you to observe the eveolution of the writer and the genesis of the ideas that spawned the mythos, which makes for fascinating reading. Now, I have to read the rest, of course.
As to the stories themselves, they seem to follow Poe's style (probably intentionally) a little too closely for easy reading, and don't break much new ground. The horors are pretty much a rehash of Victorian ideas in most cases, told in the first person. Entertaining and well-written, just not very original. Of these, the best are probably "The Tomb" and "The Festival". More original are the title story and "The Nameless City", which are dark fantasy of a little wider scope. Finally a couple of oddites: "In the Walls of Eryx" is a space opera ocurring on venus, somehting not normally associated with this author, and there's also a collaboration with Houdini.
All in all, an enjoyable place to start the Lovecraftian adventure, especially when one knows that this is the appetizer and the main course is supposed to be unbelievable... Will tell you what I think once I've read the rest!